Tag Archives: integrative medicine

Self experimentation of a science writer

Last week I managed to catch my first summer cold – courtesy of my two daughters. But unlike in past seasonable illnesses, I decided to experiment with myself, and made a conscious decision not to take any chemical remedies. I increased my daily dosage of Vitamin C, took homeopathic tablets under my tongue, applied Eucalyptus oil to my pillow, and when things got really tough, took a honey-based cough medicine.

My cold ran its normal course, and ended more or less at the same time as it would have taken if I had used various over-the-counter cold medications. True, I functioned somewhat less effectively at work and at home; and when I attended the recent Integrative Medicine Conference in Jerusalem (more on that in my next post), I may have missed a few sessions in exchange for some fresh air. But I survived. And I got better.

[I was not taking a really wild risk here. A few years ago during a family vacation, one of the children had a sore throat, and a member of our group who happened to be a doctor told the boy’s mother that he could prescribe an antibiotic, which would cure the sore throat in about seven days, or they could just let the soreness run its course, about a week. Prescribing antibiotics for a sore throat is really to prevent streptococcus, which can have serious long-term effects. But of course, not all sore throats are strep.]

Which begs the question, why is it that every minor illness, such as a seasonal cold or flu, makes many of us turn to chemical remedies? Is it that we have zero tolerance for minor discomfort? Or that society (and the workplace) cannot accept a situation of less the 100% performance?

Today I shared my decision to run this little experiment with my Chinese doctor, and our conversation naturally ran to the discussion of more serious conditions, namely menopause. Because I have no idea when menopause will become an issue in my life, I have been debating how I will handle it when the time comes. Because of my family history of breast cancer, I cannot (and will not) take the standard hormonal treatment that is usually prescribed to menopausal women. But I also know that I am very concerned about how I will deal with the hot flashes (remember I live in a very warm country) and other natural symptoms of menopause.

I am exploring the possibility of bio-identical hormones (and eagerly attended a session given at the same conference), but my doctor had another suggestion for me. When the issue becomes relevant, he suggested, we would try to handle each symptom using Chinese medicine. According to Chinese medicine, the human body is composed of two complementary opposites energy forces – the Yin (the hidden, feminine) and the Yang (the manifest, masculine). As he explained it, Yin can be viewed as a balloon, while the Yang is the block that holds it in place. During menopause, the Yang decreases, causing the Ying to rise (remember, balance), which in turn is linked to the rise in heat and hot flashes.To treat the natural symptoms of menopause, Chinese medicine increases the Yang using acupuncture and Chinese herbs, which have been in use for thousands of years, thereby allowing the natural process of menopause to continue in a way that allows a woman to continue to function and feel good.

Now I am not precluding the option of using bio-identical hormones, but for now, I feel much happier with the knowledge that I have a plan for how to deal with this inevitable stage of life. Wish me luck with my experiment!

Living with cancer – using CAM to prolong cancer remission

A cancer diagnosis used to be all but a death sentence. For my husband, diagnosed with Stage IV pancreatic carcinoma, this was still the case (because early pancreatic cancer often does not cause symptoms, pancreatic cancer is often not diagnosed until it is advanced, and complete remission is rare). Today, however, the way we view cancer is changing.

At a recent conference on integrative medicine (The Jerusalem International Conference on Integrative Medicine), I was struck by one lecture simply titled “The Integration of CAM in the treatment of chronic breast cancer.” Breast cancer as a chronic disease? I knew that survival rates for breast cancer had gone up, but the concept of breast cancer as a chronic disease – indeed the idea of living with breast cancer – seemed to be a radical change in our approach to cancer.

According to Prof. Gershom Zajicek, MD, (Professor of Experimental Medicine and Cancer Research at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem; you can find more information on his research at http://cancerandwoblistofarticles.blogspot.com/), recent evidence in cancer research suggests that, in many cases, even if the primary tumor is caught at an early stage, tumor cells have already seeded metastatic sites in a patient’s body. That was certainly the case with my mother’s breast cancer (which re-emerged as bone metastases just a few years after her initial cancer went into remission).

Prof. Zajicek refers to research published by the National Cancer Institute that shows that approximately 30 percent of the patients diagnosed with early stage breast cancer were found to have breast cancer cells in their bone marrow (http://www.cancer.gov/newscenter/ pressreleases/2008/metastaticoutreachbarkan). While these research results sound rather depressing, consider other studies Prof. Zajicek quotes (from the SEER database), which show that for many patients, breast cancer is a chronic disease, in other words a disease patients can live with for many years (www.youtube.com/watch?v=OEf96AYGFsc).

Prof. Zajicek explains that an important part of maintaining breast cancer’s status as a chronic disease is inducing prolonged remission, in which case patients are faced with two options: chemotherapy or CAM treatments. With time, however, cancer generally resists all chemotherapy. That’s when CAM becomes patients’ only therapeutic option.

What do CAM treatments do?
Using different types of CAM treatments (refer to the list at the end of this blog for some examples), therapists promote in their patients the body’s own ability to fight back – something that conventional therapies (chemotherapy and radiation) simply cannot do. Prof. Zajicek explains that CAM treatments make use of three instincts that he says directly affect the physico-chemical process in the body: a self-healing instinct, imagination (such as guided imagery), and empathy.

In this third instinct, Prof. Zajicek points out that many patients live with cancer in peace for many years. He refers to these patients as “Cancer Yogis” because, similar to the way Hindu Yogis control their physiology, Cancer Yogis control their cancer remission and may prolong it. When patients attend cancer support groups and meet these Cancer Yogis, they learn through empathy these Yogis’ way to induce remission.

Learning more about CAM and cancer treatments
You can find additional information on the use of CAM in cancer treatment at http://www.cam-cancer.org. Here are just a few of the CAM treatments used in helping cancer patients:

  • Homeopathy
  • Acupuncture (used, for example, for treating pain, hot flushes, nausea, vomiting and other side effects of chemotherapy and radiation)
  • Chinese herbal medicine
  • Biologically-based treatments (vitamins, herbs, food that promote healing, special diets)
  • Therapeutic touch treatments such as healing, Qigong, Tai-Chi, Reiki
  • Mind-body medicines such as meditation, biofeedback, hypnosis, yoga, imagery
  • Manipulative and body-based treatments such as massage, reflexology, shiatsu, pressure points
  • Welcome to Integrativity

    Welcome to Integrativity, a blog devoted to integrative and complementary medicine and its related research. In this blog, you’ll find articles and opinions about integrative medicine – and about the research that is being done in this field. You may not always agree with the ideas published here, but we believe you’ll find them interesting and thought-provoking.

    Why integrative medicine?
    Nearly 13 years ago, I was a health and science writer living in the Boston area, the very heart of medical research. As appropriate to my profession, I was skeptical, almost cynical, and unwilling to believe in anything that could not be proven with pure scientific evidence. As I was taught by my journalism professors, my motto was always ‘just the facts, ma’am’. My skepticism was always highest when it came to so-called “new age” therapies, which could supposedly heal a person where conventional medicine had failed.

    And then my husband was diagnosed with advanced pancreatic cancer. Stage four, to be precise, and his chances of beating the disease were slim to none. And no, he was not miraculously healed by a Chinese doctor, or cured by a Native American Shaman. He was very sick, and in terrible pain, but what our Chinese doctor was able to do through acupuncture, healing, and herbs was to give him enough respite to feel comfortable. Enough respite from the pain and depression to be able to pick up our daughter from kindergarten, to be able to go out occasionally to dinner or to friends, to be able to get up in the morning and go to his chemotherapy treatments.

    This story does not have a happy ending. My husband beat the odds for longer than most of his doctors could have hoped, but eventually the disease won, and we lost a dear, wonderful man. His experience, however, opened my eyes to the possibility that not everything has to be based on pure evidence. Through his experience, he enabled me to suspend my disbelief, and to begin a journey that has brought me to this point.

    Whether you are someone who believes in alternative medicine, or have mixed feelings about it, or are a practitioner yourself – alternative or otherwise – I believe you will find this blog interesting, fair, and frank. I welcome your feedback, and hope that the Integrativity blog becomes a place where integrative medicine can be discussed with integrity.

    Anna Aleksandrowicz